Serving Ohio and the Midwest

Insure Your...
Auto
Home
Business
Motorcycle / ATV

Watercraft

Find Out About...
Health Insurance
Life Insurance
SR-22 Bonds




To report your claim directly by phone, follow these simple instructions:

  1. Have your policy number on hand.

  2. Click on the name of your insurance company in the list below.

  3. Locate the company's claims phone number. If more than one claims phone number is listed, select the number closest to you.

  4. Call the claims number and an insurance company claims representative will take it from there.

Some insurance companies also offer online claims reporting and service. Visit Online Service to find out your options for online claims service. If you have any questions or cannot reach your insurance company, call Watkins & Keyerleber at 1-800-321-4627.

 

Insurance Company Contact Information
Allstate
American Modern Insurance Group, Inc.
Condon & Skelly
Dairyland Insurance Company
Fidelity & Guaranty Life
Foremost
GMAC Insurance Company
GoAmerica Auto Insurance
Golden Rule Insurance Company
GuideOne Insurance Company
Heritage/Acuity Insurance Company
Integon Insurance Company
K&K Insurance Group, Inc.
Leader National Insurance
National Flood Insurance Program
Ohio Fair Plan
Progressive Insurance Co.
Reliant National Insurance Co.
Travelers Insurance Co.
Universal Underwriters
Western Reserve Group
Western Surety Company


Allstate
Phone Numbers
Service: 1-877-597-0570
Cincinnati Claims: 1-800-686-2102
Cleveland Claims: 1-800-686-9990
Columbus Claims: 1-800-686-8404
Dayton Claims: 1-800-686-1130
Toledo Claims: 1-800-686-2751
Youngstown Claims: 1-800-589-2266
Mailing Address
Allstate
Midwest Indemnity Territorial
PO Box 3194
Arlington Hts, IL 60006-9937
www.allstate.com


American Modern Insurance Group, Inc.
Phone Numbers
Service: 1-800-759-9008
Claims: 1-800-375-2075
Mailing Address
American Modern Insurance Group, Inc.
PO Box 5323
Cincinnati, OH 45201-5323
www.amig.com


Back to Top

Condon & Skelly
Phone Numbers
Service & Claims: 1-800-257-9496
Mailing Address
Condon & Skelly
121 East Kings Hwy, Ste 203
Maple Shade, NJ 08052
www.condonskelly.com


Dairyland Insurance Company
Phone Numbers
Service: 1-888-324-7952
Claims: 1-800-338-2487
Mailing Address
Dairyland Insurance Company
PO Box 35748
Richmond, VA 23235-0748
www.dairylandins.com


Back to Top

Fidelity & Guaranty Life
Phone Numbers
Service: 1-800-638-2255
Mailing Address
Fidelity & Guaranty Life Service Center
P.O. Box 19044
Greenville, SC 29602
www.fglife.com


Foremost Insurance Group
Phone Numbers
Service: 1-800-239-5877
Claims: 1-800-527-3907
Mailing Address
Foremost Insurance Group
5600 Beech Tree Lane
Caledonia, MI 49316
www.foremost.com


Back to Top

GMAC Insurance Company
Phone Numbers
Service & Claims: 1-877-468-3466
Mailing Address
GMAC Insurance Company
500 West Fifth St.
PO Box 3310
Winston-Salem, NC 27199-7020
www.gmacins.com


GoAmerica Auto Insurance
Phone Numbers
Service: 1-800-876-3500
Claims: 1-888-285-8620
Mailing Address
GoAmerica Auto Insurance
PO Box 6070
Indianapolis, IN 46206-6070
www.goamericaautoins.com


Back to Top

Golden Rule Insurance Company
Mailing Address
Golden Rule Insurance Company
Golden Rule Building
7440 Woodland Dr
Indianapolis, IN 46278-1719
www.goldenrule.com


GuideOne Insurance Company
Phone Numbers
Service: 1-800-247-4176
Claims: 1-888-748-4326
Mailing Address
GuideOne Insurance Company
PO Box 14530
Des Moines, IA 50306-3530
www.guideone.com


Back to Top

Heritage/Acuity Insurance Company
Phone Numbers
Service: 1-920-458-9131
Claims: 1-800-242-7666
Mailing Address
Heritage Insurance
2800 Taylor Dr
PO Box 58
Sheyboygan, WI 53082-0058
www.acuityfin.com


Integon Insurance Company
Phone Numbers
Service & Claims: 1-877-468-3466
Mailing Address
Integon Insurance
500 West Fifth St.
PO Box 3310
Winston-Salem, NC 27199-7020
www.gmacins.com


Back to Top

K&K Insurance Group, Inc.
Phone Numbers
Service: 1-800-637-4757
Claims: 1-800-237-2917
Mailing Address
K&K Insurance Group
Motorsports Division
1712 Magnavox Way
PO Box 2338
Fort Wayne, IN 46801-2338
www.kandkinsurance.com


Leader National Insurance
Phone Numbers
Service: 1-877-953-2337
Claims: 1-800-788-2200
Mailing Address
Leader National Insurance
PO Box 650328
Dallas, TX 75265-0328
www.leaderinsurance.com


Back to Top

National Flood Insurance Program
Phone Numbers
1-888-CALL-FLOOD ext. 445
Mailing Address
NFIP
PO Box 6464
Rockville, MD 20849-6464
www.fema.gov/nfip


Ohio Fair Plan
Phone Numbers
Service: 1-614-839-6446
Mailing Address
Ohio Fair Plan
6230 Busch Blvd., ST 303
Columbus, OH 43229
www.ohiofairplan.com


Back to Top

Progressive Insurance Co.
Phone Numbers
Service: 1-877-776-4266
Claims: 1-800-274-4499
Mailing Address
Progressive Insurance
PO Box 6807
Cleveland, OH 44101-1807
www.progressive.com


Reliant National Insurance Co.
Phone Numbers
Service: 1-888-888-0080
Claims: 1-800-680-8020
Mailing Address
Reliant National Insurance
PO Box 94585
Cleveland, OH 44101-4585
www.reliantins.com


Back to Top

Travelers Insurance Co.
Mailing Address
Travelers Insurance Co.
One Tower Square
Hartford, CT 06183-4075
www.travelers.com


Universal Underwriters
Phone Numbers
Service & Claims: 1-800-238-2446
Mailing Address
Universal Underwriters Group
6363 College Blvd.
Overland Park, KS 66211-1551
www.rpiinsurance.com


Back to Top

Western Reserve Group
Phone Numbers
Service & Claims: 1-800-362-0426
Mailing Address
Western Reserve Group
PO Box 36
Wooster, OH 44691-0036
www.wrg-ins.com


Western Surety Company
Phone Numbers
Service: 1-888-736-9704
Claims: 1-800-331-6053
Mailing Address
Western Surety Company
PO Box 5077
Sioux Falls, SD 57117-5077
www.cnasurety.com